Welcome to Cicero's
At Cicero's, located in Bardonia, NY, our story is one of transformation and commitment to quality. Formerly a hidden gem, Cicero's has blossomed into a vibrant dining destination, boasting modern décor and a warm atmosphere. Our menu features an array of delectable options, from fresh salads like the Greek Salad to artisanal pizzas baked to perfection. Customers rave about our ample portions and consistency across dishes, fostering a loyal community. As we prioritize customer satisfaction, our attentive staff ensures each visit is memorable. Embrace the flavors of Cicero's, where good food and great company come together.
Cicero's: Reviews & Ratings
Great to go meals. Ample portions and good quality.
Fantastic food at great prices. Always recommended. My only gripe is sometimes the food taste is a bit inconsistent based on who the cook of the day is
Really glad I gave ciceros another shot. It’s been years since I went in there and the place has changed a lot. The decor is modern and pleasant. The help is polite and attentive. The pizza is pretty good too. Will definitely go back sometime to try some of the Greek menu items and sit down in their new dining room.
This place is nice. Plenty of tables and seats. Cool bar area. I take my daughter here for lunch with her grandma all the time. Menu is nice. Decent prices for the food. I'll Def keep coming here. Great atmosphere. Great food and pizza.
Ordered a pie in the last hour of closing and got there in 10 minutes and my order was ready and hot. Price is fantastic. Pizza had a nice fresh layer of cheese; rather than overcooked, it was stringy and white when we were eating it. Girl are the counter was a sweetheart. Didn't know it existed and it's right around the corner.
Food is consistently excellent! I’m a fan of the Greek salad and the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Their Sicilian slices are also top notch.
Always the best pizza. Best chicken and salad. Favorite pizza in Rockland.
Love this place! Now to be fair I have only eaten the Lamb Gyro here. But once you have the lamb gyro not sure you’d want to try anything else. Just kidding I’m sure their other offerings are equally mouthgasmic. The gyro is in a pita the lamb is sliced thin and super tasty, the Tzatziki sauce is incredible, they only put tomato chunks and thinly sliced red onion on it with the Tzatziki and mmm mmm is it delicious!
Location
-
71 Bardonia Rd, Bardonia, NY 10954, United States Hotline: +1 845-627-3436
Welcome to the culinary haven known as Cicero's, a delightful eatery tucked away at 71 Bardonia Rd, Bardonia, NY 10954. This charming spot has garnered attention for its impeccable balance of flavors, hearty portions, and warm atmosphere. Whether you're in the mood for a casual dine-in experience or a hearty meal to-go, Cicero’s caters to every palate.
What sets Cicero's apart is its diverse menu, which features an enticing blend of traditional Greek and Italian dishes. Their Meze selection is a true highlight, showcasing items like Saganaki, a delicious pan-seared honey Kefalograviera cheese topped with aromatic sesame seeds and served with a drizzle of Greek honey. Diners will surely enjoy the Octopus, tenderly prepared Spanish octopus paired with vibrant red onions and chickpeas, creating a delightful mix of textures and flavors.
- Gigandes: Classic Greek lima beans tossed with fresh tomatoes for a refreshing touch.
- Greek Wings: Oven-roasted wings seasoned with a flavorful dry rub, perfect for savory cravings.
- Olive Medley: A selection of marinated olives infused with fresh herbs, a simple yet satisfying appetizer.
- Roasted Beets: Red and golden beets served with skordalia, showcasing a beautiful color contrast and taste.
For those craving heartier fare, the Parmigiana options are certainly worth a try—from the Shrimp Parmigiana to the classic Italian Combo, each dish delivers rich flavors from perfectly cooked ingredients. And for pizza lovers, Cicero's offers an array of calzones and pizzas that have earned rave reviews, noted for their ample portions and quality—all at a price that won't break the bank.
Customer experiences underscore Cicero’s appeal. With reviews highlighting the modern decor, polite service, and a commitment to quality, it’s easy to see why locals keep returning. One eager diner, Anthony “Tony” Letizia, expressed enthusiasm after revisiting the restaurant, commenting on both the inviting atmosphere and the improvements made. Similarly, customers like Zoe have praised the prompt service during late-night orders, further solidifying Cicero's reputation as a convenient choice for fresh, tasty meals.
For a lively dining experience paired with a comforting menu, Cicero's truly delivers. With a welcoming atmosphere and a mix of classic and modern dishes, it beckons food enthusiasts and families alike to discover a place where great meals and memorable moments come together. Don’t just take our word for it; venture to this Bardonia gem and taste the excellence for yourself!